Is Selena Gomez better than Miley Cyrus?

[Haybabygirl]

Heyyy

I am just wondering if you think which disney star is better!

Wizards of wivally place's:
Selena Gomez



Hannah Montana's:
Miley Cyrus



I honstly say i like both of these stars but i pefer Miley!

[RoverBowden]

I think Selena is better as an actress and has a better voice.

[ChattyGirl247]

Both are really good singers and actress but I prefer Miley a little more. Actually, someone who I think is almost as good as Miley is Demi Lovato from As the Bell Rings and the upcoming movie Camp Rock.

[BABii_ANG3L]

I don't know, really. Miley is pretty overrated (not to offend anyone here) and Selena is okay.

[riot]

I used to like Miley a lot, but she says one thing and does another and always ends up apologizing.
But as far as acting & singing, I think Miley's a little better than Selena.

[RuleroftheWorld]

They're both manufactured stars, and neither got where they are by being massively talented (like so many stars to be honest). Ive not seen too much of Selena, but Miley is massively, massively over-rated, shes an AWFUL actress, and her singing is passable, but then how much "studio magic" has been applied to her voice to make it passable?

I'd say Selena - even though Ive not seen much of her - for the simple reason that Miley is so bad, Selena can't be worst.

My opinion.

[TwiHardPotterFan]

I like Miley better myself but a magazine I read recently is calling Selena the new Miley

[Thumper]

They're both manufactured stars, and neither got where they are by being massively talented (like so many stars to be honest). Ive not seen too much of Selena, but Miley is massively, massively over-rated, shes an AWFUL actress, and her singing is passable, but then how much "studio magic" has been applied to her voice to make it passable?

I'd say Selena - even though Ive not seen much of her - for the simple reason that Miley is so bad, Selena can't be worst.

My opinion.

That's what I think Andy. I don't like either of them. They drive me nuts, overrated teenage stars.

[Shambler]

For the first time I heard Miley speak the other night, on E! Entertainment Channel. They showed her at a concert or whatever apologizing for her 'almost nude' photos. To be perfectly blunt, she speaks like a man, looks like a horse, and sings like every other average pop star out there.


On that basis, I'll go with Selena Gomez - dunno much about her, and thats a good thing! Means she's not as over exposed as that other kid.

[margotchanning]

I didn't realise their voices were audible to anyone over 18 - a bit like Bats!........Ooops did I say that out loud?